When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Welcome to Toad's Collectibles!
Your trusted source for Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon (including Japanese singles), and Flesh & Blood. We focus on premium card quality, transparent grading, and exceptional value.
Special Offers & Store Perks
Buy More, Save More: Buy 6, Get $5 Off all cards under $20! Infinitely redeemable and stacks across a single order.
Free Collectible Sticker: Every order includes a complimentary sticker featuring our mascot, Toadwick the Curator!
100% Satisfaction Guarantee: Fully insured shipments with free returns. If you are not satisfied, we will make it right.
Shipping & Packaging Standards
All cards ship securely with sleeves and rigid protection within 1 business day (3–7 day delivery).
Singles Under $20: Shipped via Standard Envelope (tracked & insured).
Singles Over $20 / Orders Over $50: Packed securely in toploaders and cardboard slabs inside a bubble mailer via USPS Ground Advantage (tracked & insured).
Condition Grading Scale
Near Mint (NM): Crisp condition. 0–2 minor spots of edge whitening; no scratches, dents, creases, bends, or off-centering.
Lightly Played (LP): Minor play. 3–5 whitening spots, light holofoil scratching; no dents or structural bends.
Moderately Played (MP): Moderate wear. 6+ whitening spots, surface scratching, or minor creases/dents.
Heavily Played (HP): Heavy wear. Extensive whitening, deep scratches, and noticeable bends/creases.
(Most inventory comes directly from sealed product, though third-party grades like PSA/CGC are not guaranteed).
Store Policies & Contact
Card Images: Listings with multiple quantities use representative stock photos. Message us directly if you need photos of a specific card!
We Buy Sealed: We actively purchase sealed products in volume. Contact us on Instagram or TikTok to sell.
Follow Us: Click the heart on our storefront for exclusive coupons, and follow @toadscollectibles on TikTok & Instagram. Direct message us anytime with questions!
